The scale of the problem
Most Australians assume estate disputes happen to other families. The numbers suggest otherwise.
~60%
of Australians have a written will — meaning roughly 8.3 million adults do not
$2.4 trillion
in assets expected to transfer from Baby Boomers to the next generation
~620,000
existing wills are expected to be contested across Australia
8.27 million
Australian adults estimated to have no will in place (ABS, 2022)
Australia is in the early stages of one of the largest intergenerational wealth transfers in its history. Baby Boomers — those born between 1946 and 1964 — hold a significant portion of the nation’s private wealth. As that wealth passes on, disputes over how it is distributed are becoming more frequent, more complex, and higher in value.
When an estate involves substantial assets — property, business interests, investment portfolios, trusts — the stakes are real and so are the legal risks. Failing to act promptly can result in an estate being distributed before a claim is brought, or a limitation period running out.
Types of will and estate disputes we handle
Family provision claims
Under Queensland’s Succession Act 1981, certain eligible persons — including spouses, children, and dependants — may apply for adequate provision from an estate if they believe the will, or the intestacy rules, have left them without fair support. These claims are time-sensitive. In Queensland, an eligible person generally has nine months from the date of death to make a claim.
Challenging testamentary capacity
A will is only valid if the person who made it had the mental capacity to understand what they were doing. Where a testator was suffering from dementia, cognitive decline, or another condition affecting their judgment at the time the will was made, the document may be open to challenge. Medical evidence and chronology matter greatly in these cases.
Undue influence and coercion
A will must reflect the genuine intentions of the person who made it. Where a beneficiary has used manipulation, pressure, or coercion to shape the contents of a will — particularly in the context of elder care, caregiving relationships, or financial dependency — that document may be challenged on grounds of undue influence. These cases require careful evidence gathering and a clear factual narrative.
Will validity and formal requirements
A will that was not properly executed — not witnessed correctly, signed under duress, or altered without authority — may be challenged on formal validity grounds. Informal documents that may represent testamentary intentions (such as handwritten notes or letters) can also give rise to litigation about whether they should be recognised as valid wills.
Executor disputes and removal
When an executor is failing in their duties — acting in their own interest, failing to administer the estate diligently, or creating conflict with beneficiaries — there are legal mechanisms to have them removed or compelled to act. We advise both executors who face such proceedings and beneficiaries who need to bring them.
Estate and trust construction disputes
Poorly drafted wills and trust deeds often produce disputes about what the document actually means. Where the wording of a will is ambiguous or its operation unclear, the matter may require judicial determination. These disputes sit at the intersection of property law, trust law, and litigation — territory Boyle Litigation navigates regularly.
How Boyle Litigation approaches will disputes
We are a commercial litigation firm. We do not do estate planning, probate administration, or general wills and estates work. What we do is disputes — and we bring that same strategic, outcome-driven approach to every estate matter we handle.
That means we start at the end and work backwards. Before committing to litigation, we identify: the realistic value of the claim, the strength of the evidence, the likely defences, the costs exposure, and the most efficient path to resolution — whether that is a negotiated outcome, mediation, or court proceedings.
Estate disputes can settle. Many do. But they settle better — and faster — when the other side knows you have the litigation capability to follow through.