Unfair Preferences: How Liquidators Recover Payments Made Before Winding Up

If a company pays a creditor in the months before it goes into liquidation, that payment may be ‘clawed back’ by the liquidator—even if the payment was entirely legitimate at the time it was made. This is the unfair preference regime.

Received a demand from a liquidator? Take it seriously.

Book a confidential strategy call

What Is an Unfair Preference?

An unfair preference is a transaction by which a company, when insolvent, gives one of its unsecured creditors an advantage over other unsecured creditors—by paying a debt, settling a judgment, or otherwise improving that creditor’s position—in the period before winding up.

The policy rationale is equality among creditors (pari passu). A creditor who receives payment when the company is insolvent has been preferred over others who received nothing—so the payment is unwound and returned to the pool for equitable distribution.

The Statutory Test: s588FA

Under s588FA of the Corporations Act, a transaction is an unfair preference given to a creditor if:

  • The company and the creditor are parties to the transaction
  • The transaction results in the creditor receiving more in relation to the company’s debts than it would have received in the winding up had the transaction not occurred

Importantly, the transaction need not be intentionally preferential—it is sufficient that the effect was to give the creditor more than they would have received in the liquidation.

The Look-Back Period

To be voidable as an unfair preference, the transaction must occur in the ‘relation-back period’. For unsecured creditors, this is six months before the relation-back day (generally the date of the winding up application or voluntary appointment). For related parties (related creditors), the look-back period is extended to four years.

See the dedicated article on Relation-Back Day and Look-Back Periods (I08) for more on how these periods work.

The Defenses: S588FG

A creditor who received a preference can defend the claim under s588FG if they can establish:

Good faith (s588FG(2)(a))The creditor received the transaction in good faith.
No reasonable grounds (s588FG(2)(b))At the time, the creditor had no reasonable grounds to suspect the company was insolvent (or would become insolvent by reason of the transaction).
Valuable consideration (s588FG(2)(c))The creditor provided valuable consideration under the transaction or changed their position in reliance on it

All three elements must be established. The creditor bears the burden of proof on the defense.

The Running Account Defence

For creditors who had an ongoing trading relationship with the company—continuing to supply goods or services while receiving payments—the running account principle under s588FA(3) is important. The court treats the entire course of dealing as a single transaction, looking at the net effect: did the creditor’s overall position improve over the relation-back period? If the net position is neutral or adverse (creditor received less than the new credit they extended), there may be no preference.

Related Party Transactions

Where a preference is paid to a related party (a director, their family, or a related company), the look-back period is four years and the good faith defense is harder to establish. Courts scrutinize related party payments closely in insolvency matters.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can a secured creditor be pursued for an unfair preference?

A: Secured creditors enforcing their security are generally not subject to preference claims—they receive payment as a secured creditor, not an unsecured creditor. However, if the security was granted during the preference period (and is itself a voidable transaction), the analysis changes.

Q: What is the difference between an unfair preference and an uncommercial transaction?

A: An unfair preference is about a creditor receiving more than they would in the winding up. An uncommercial transaction (S588FB) is about the company making a transaction that a reasonable person in the company’s position would not have made—regardless of who benefits. See I03.

Q: Does the creditor have to return the whole amount?

A: If the preference claim is made out, the creditor must repay the amount of the preference. However, if the creditor has a set-off—for example, an outstanding debt owed by the company—this may reduce what must be repaid.

Q: Can the liquidator recover from a creditor who has gone bankrupt?

A: Yes—the liquidator can prove in the creditor’s bankruptcy for the preference amount. Recovery may be limited by the creditor’s own insolvency.

Q: How long does a liquidator have to bring a preference claim?

A: The limitation period for preference claims is generally six years from the commencement of the winding up. Liquidators should act within this period, though courts have power to extend time in appropriate cases.

Q: Can a creditor negotiate with the liquidator before proceedings are issued?

A: Yes. Most preference claims are resolved by negotiation before proceedings are commenced. Liquidators have duties to creditors and will often accept a commercial settlement—particularly where the good faith defense appears strong.

Related Articles

Explore more insights, legal updates, and practical guidance from our litigation experts.
Scroll to Top