Uncommercial Transactions: When Liquidators Set Aside Bad Bargains

When a company transfers property, provides services, or enters a transaction at a significant undervalue before insolvency, a liquidator can apply to the court to set it aside. Section 588FB of the Corporations Act gives liquidators this power—regardless of whether the counterparty knew the company was in trouble.

Involved in a transaction with a company now in liquidation?

Book a confidential strategy call

What Is an Uncommercial Transaction?

Section 588FB defines an uncommercial transaction as a transaction entered into by a company where it may be expected that a reasonable person in the company’s position would not have entered into the transaction, having regard to:

  • The benefits (if any) to the company of entering into it
  • The detriment to the company of entering into it
  • The respective benefits to other parties to the transaction
  • Any other relevant matter

Classic examples include selling property at a significant undervalue, paying debts for no consideration, providing guarantees with no benefit to the company, or assigning assets to related parties for nominal consideration.

Look-Back Periods: S588FE

Under s588FE, an uncommercial transaction is voidable if it was entered into during the following periods before the relation-back day:

General (unrelated party)Two years before the relation-back day
Related party transactionFour years before the relation-back day
Transaction to defeat creditors (with intent)Ten years before the relation-back day (if intended to defraud creditors)

The Reasonable Person Test

The test is objective. The question is not what the company’s directors believed at the time, but what a reasonable person in the company’s position—knowing what the company knew and facing what it faced—would have done. This is a broad inquiry that considers commercial context, market conditions, and the company’s financial position.

Defenses: S588FG

The good faith defense in s588FG is available to uncommercial transaction claims. A counterparty can establish the defense if, at the time of the transaction:

  • They received the transaction in good faith
  • They had no reasonable grounds to suspect the company was insolvent
  • They provided valuable consideration or changed their position in reliance on the transaction

Remedies If the Transaction Is Set Aside

If the court sets aside an uncommercial transaction under s588FF, it can make orders to:

  • Require a party to pay money to the company
  • Transfer property back to the company
  • Discharge a security or charge granted by the company
  • Order compensation in lieu of restitution

Courts have a broad discretion in crafting the remedy and will seek to restore the company’s position, not to penalize innocent parties. A counterparty who provides genuine consideration and acts in good faith is protected.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Does the counterparty need to know the company was insolvent?

A: No. The uncommercial transaction test does not require the counterparty to have known of insolvency—the claim is made out if the transaction was uncommercial on its objective terms. However, knowledge of insolvency (or grounds for suspicion) undermines the good faith defense.

Q: How is ‘reasonable person’ assessed in a distressed sale?

A: Courts acknowledge that a company in financial difficulty may accept less than market value to secure a quick sale. A distressed sale is not automatically uncommercial—the question is whether the transaction was within the range of what a reasonable person in those circumstances would have accepted.

Q: What is the difference between s588FB and s588FDA?

A: Section 588FB is about transactions that no reasonable company would have entered—focusing on the company’s perspective. Section 588FDA (unreasonable director-related transactions) focuses specifically on transactions with directors or their associates that an objective person would not have approved.

Q: Can a liquidator claim both unfair preference and uncommercial transaction on the same transaction?

A: Yes. A transaction can potentially be both—for example, a payment to a related creditor that was also at a significant undervalue. The liquidator can plead both and the court will determine which applies.

Q: Does a joint venture or restructuring agreement fall within s588FB?

A: It can. Restructuring transactions entered into when the company is near insolvency—particularly where the benefit flows predominantly to the other party—are scrutinized. Professional advice obtained at the time of the transaction is relevant to the defence.

Q: What happens to a security interest if the underlying transaction is set aside?

A: If a transaction that created a security interest is set aside, the court can order that the security be voided or discharged. The PPSA priority rules interact with this analysis in complex ways.

Related Articles

Explore more insights, legal updates, and practical guidance from our litigation experts.
Scroll to Top