Director Duty Breach: Compensation Orders Under s1317H in Liquidation

When a company enters liquidation and the conduct of its directors has caused loss, the liquidator has standing to pursue those directors for compensation. The statutory duty regime—ss180 to 184 of the Corporations Act—is the primary basis for those claims.

Director conduct under scrutiny in a liquidation?

Book a confidential strategy call

The Statutory Duties: ss180-184

The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) imposes four core statutory duties on company directors and officers:

S180—Care and DiligenceExercise powers and discharge duties with the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person in that position would exercise. Includes the business judgment rule defense in s180(2).
S181—Good FaithExercise powers and discharge duties in good faith in the best interests of the corporation and for a proper purpose.
S182—Improper Use of PositionNot improperly use position to gain advantage for themselves or someone else, or to cause detriment to the corporation.
S183—Improper Use of InformationNot improperly use information obtained by reason of position to gain advantage or cause detriment.

Section 184 elevates ss181-183 to criminal offenses where the conduct is dishonest or reckless. ASIC can pursue criminal charges; liquidators pursue civil claims.

The Business Judgment Rule: s180(2)

A director who makes a business judgment satisfies S180 if they:

  • Make the judgment in good faith for a proper purpose
  • Do not have a material personal interest in the subject matter of the judgment
  • Inform themselves about the subject matter to the extent they reasonably believe is appropriate
  • Rationally believe the judgment is in the best interests of the corporation

The business judgment rule protects commercially reasonable decisions, even those that turn out badly. It does not protect abdication of responsibility, rubber-stamping, or decisions made without any real analysis.

Compensation Orders: s1317H

Where a director contravenes a civil penalty provision (including ss180-183), the court can, under s1317H, order the director to compensate the company for damage suffered as a result of the contravention. The liquidator sues in the company’s name; any compensation recovered flows to the general pool.

The damage must be caused by the contravention. This is a causation requirement—the liquidator must establish a link between the breach and the loss, not merely that a breach occurred and a loss exists.

Civil Penalty Orders: s1317E

In addition to (or instead of) a compensation order, the court can impose civil penalties on directors who contravene the duty provisions. Maximum penalties for serious breaches can be significant—as at the current legislation, pecuniary penalties for corporate provisions can reach millions of dollars. Civil penalty proceedings are typically brought by ASIC, but a liquidator’s duty breach claim can sit alongside ASIC action.

The Overlap with Insolvent Trading

A director who allows a company to trade while insolvent breaches both s588G (insolvent trading) and potentially s180 (failing to act with care and diligence). Liquidators often plead both — s588G for the specific insolvent trading recovery and s180/s1317H, where other conduct caused additional loss not covered by the specific insolvent trading claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can a director be sued by the liquidator for decisions made years before liquidation?

A: Yes—the limitation period is generally six years from the date of the breach. The relevant date is when the breach occurred, not when the company entered liquidation. The look-back depends on when specific decisions were made and what duties they engaged.

Q: What defenses does a director have against an S180 claim?

A: The business judgment rule (s180(2)) is the primary defense—the director must show they made an informed, good-faith judgment they rationally believed was in the company’s interest. Reliance on professional advice (legal, financial) is also relevant, provided the reliance was reasonable.

Q: Can a director be personally bankrupt as a result of an S1317H order?

A: Yes. A compensation order under s1317H is enforceable as a money judgment. If the director cannot pay, bankruptcy proceedings are available. This is a personal liability that cannot be limited by the corporate structure.

Q: Can indemnity insurance cover an S1317H claim?

A: Directors and officers insurance (D&O) may cover defense costs and some compensation orders. However, coverage for dishonest or fraudulent conduct (including S184 criminal conduct) is typically excluded. Whether a particular claim is covered depends on the policy terms.

Q: What is the role of ASIC in director duty breach claims?

A: ASIC has the primary power to bring civil penalty proceedings for breach of directors’ duties. A liquidator can bring a compensation claim under s1317H but cannot obtain civil penalties—those are reserved for ASIC. The two sets of proceedings can run concurrently.

Q: How does a liquidator fund a duty breach claim against a director?

A: Liquidators often lack sufficient funds in the estate to pursue directors. Options include litigation funding agreements with third-party funders, an assignment of the claim to a funder, or ASIC’s co-contribution scheme for eligible cases. Legal advice on the funding structure is critical.

Related Articles

Explore more insights, legal updates, and practical guidance from our litigation experts.
Scroll to Top