Creditor-Defeating Dispositions: Section 588FDB and the Extended Recovery Regime

Section 588FDB is one of the newest tools in the insolvency recovery arsenal. Introduced as part of the Treasury Laws Amendment (Combating Illegal Phoenixing) Act 2020 (Cth), it targets dispositions of assets made to defeat, delay, or interfere with the claims of creditors—with consequences for both companies and the directors who authorize them.

Assets transferred before a company’s collapse? Legal advice is urgent.

Book a confidential strategy call

What Is a Creditor-Defeating Disposition?

Under s588FDB(1) of the Corporations Act, a disposition of property is a creditor-defeating disposition if:

  • The consideration for the disposition is less than the lesser of (i) the market value of the property at the time of the disposition or (ii) the best price reasonably obtainable for the property at that time
  • The disposition has the effect of preventing, hindering, or significantly delaying the property becoming available for distribution to creditors in a winding up

This is a broad, effects-based test. It does not require intent to defraud—the question is whether the disposition in fact puts assets beyond the reach of creditors, combined with inadequate consideration.

Why Was s588FDB Introduced?

The existing uncommercial transaction regime (s588FB) requires insolvency at or near the time of the transaction (within the look-back period). Section 588FDB was designed to address asset-stripping before formal insolvency is triggered—the phoenix activity pattern where assets are transferred from a failing company to a new entity before winding up.

The Ten-Year Look-Back Period

Section 588FE(6B) provides a ten-year look-back period for creditor-defeating dispositions. This is the longest look-back period in the voidable transaction regime. It reflects the seriousness of deliberate asset-stripping conduct and the long gap that can exist between a disposition and the formal commencement of a winding up.

Director Liability: S588GAB

Where a company makes a creditor-defeating disposition, the director who authorized or caused the disposition can also be personally liable under s588GAB. Civil penalty orders can be made against the director—separate from the company’s liability—to have the transaction set aside. This makes s588FDB a powerful tool for liquidators pursuing both asset recovery and director accountability.

See the dedicated article on Phoenix Activity and S588GAB (I10) for more on director liability for creditor-defeating conduct.

Defenses Under s588FDB(2)

A transaction is not a creditor-defeating disposition if:

  • The consideration was not less than the market value or best obtainable price (i.e., a genuine market transaction)
  • The disposition was made in good faith for the purposes of a genuine restructuring
  • The disposition was approved by the court

The genuine restructuring defense requires more than a general intention to restructure—there must be a credible plan with a reasonable prospect of a better outcome for creditors than winding up. Contemporaneous documentation is critical.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the difference between s588FDB and s588FB (uncommercial transactions)?

A: Section 588FB requires the transaction to be uncommercial at the time—tested against what a reasonable person in the company’s position would have done. Section 588FDB focuses specifically on dispositions at an undervalue that have the effect of defeating creditors, with a much longer look-back period and director liability under s588GAB.

Q: Does the party receiving the asset face personal liability?

A: Under the voidable transaction regime, the liquidator can seek orders requiring return of the property or compensation from the recipient. Directors who authorized the disposition face civil penalties under s588GAB—separate proceedings.

Q: Can S588FDB apply to a sale of a business for genuine value?

A: No—if the consideration was genuinely at market value (or the best obtainable price), the transaction is not a creditor-defeating disposition. The key question is whether the price reflected the true value of the asset at the time.

Q: What evidence does a liquidator need to establish a creditor-defeating disposition?

A: The liquidator typically requires a valuation of the asset at the time of the disposition, evidence of the consideration received, and analysis of the effect of the disposition on the company’s available assets. Expert valuation evidence is commonly required.

Q: Can ASIC bring an action for creditor-defeating dispositions?

A: Yes. ASIC has enforcement powers in relation to s588FDB and s588GAB. This is one of the provisions designed to give regulators a role in combating phoenix activity, rather than leaving enforcement entirely to liquidators.

Q: What is the interaction with PPSA security interests?

A: Where a creditor-defeating disposition involves the grant or enforcement of a security interest, the interaction with the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) is complex. Legal advice on the priority and voidability analysis is essential.

Related Articles

Explore more insights, legal updates, and practical guidance from our litigation experts.
Scroll to Top