One of the most powerful investigative tools available to a liquidator is the right to compel a director, officer, or other person to appear before the court and answer questions about the company’s affairs. Sections 596A and 596B of the Corporations Act make this possible—and non-compliance is a criminal offense.
Summonsed to attend a public examination?
Book a confidential strategy call
What Are the S596A and S596B Examinations?
Section 596A and 596B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) empower a court to summons a person to appear and be examined about the examinable affairs of a company that is under external administration (including liquidation).
| s596A | The court must issue a summons if the applicant is an eligible applicant (the liquidator, ASIC, or a creditor) and the person to be examined is an ‘officer’ of the company (including current and former directors, secretaries, and employees). The court has no discretion—it must issue the summons. |
| s596B | The court may issue a summons (discretionary) to any other person (including third parties such as banks, advisers, or business associates) who is believed to have information about the company’s examinable affairs. |
Examinable Affairs: What Can Be Asked?
‘Examinable affairs’ is defined broadly in s9 of the Corporations Act to include:
- The promotion, formation, management, administration, or winding up of the company
- Any act or omission of, or relating to, a person who was an officer or promoter of the company
- The business, trading, dealings, affairs, or property of the company
Courts have interpreted examinable affairs broadly. Questions can go well beyond the formal winding-up process to cover the company’s commercial history, the conduct of its principals, and transactions with third parties.
How the Examination Proceeds
Examinations are conducted before a registrar or judge of the relevant court. The process is quasi-judicial:
- The examinee is under oath or affirmation
- Counsel for the liquidator (and possibly ASIC or creditors) may ask questions
- The examination is transcribed, and the transcript forms part of the court record
- The examinee may be represented by counsel, but counsel’s role is limited—the examinee must answer the questions themselves
Privileges and Protections
Examinees are not without protection:
- Legal professional privilege—questions requiring disclosure of privileged communications can be objected to, but the privilege is the company’s, not the director’s, and may have been lost if the company’s books are in the liquidator’s hands
- Self-incrimination—the privilege against self-incrimination is available in some circumstances but is significantly curtailed in S596 examinations. Answers given under compulsion may be used in civil (but not necessarily criminal) proceedings under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s128A
Consequences of Non-Compliance
Failure to comply with a summons to attend an examination is a criminal offense under s597(5). The court can also issue an arrest warrant for a person who fails to appear without reasonable cause.
The Liquidator’s Purpose: Information and Proceedings
Liquidators use examinations to:
- Gather evidence to support preference, insolvent trading, or director duty breach claims
- Trace assets that may have been transferred or dissipated
- Identify related parties and associated transactions
- Establish the timeline of the company’s financial deterioration
Information obtained in an examination can be used in subsequent proceedings brought by the liquidator or ASIC.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can a director refuse to answer questions at a s596 examination?
A: Only on valid privilege grounds. The privilege against self-incrimination may apply but is limited—the court may make orders allowing the use of answers in civil proceedings. Directors should attend with experienced legal counsel.
Q: Who can apply for an S596 examination?
A: Eligible applicants under s596A include the liquidator, ASIC, and certain creditors. Under s596B (discretionary), anyone with a legitimate interest in the company’s affairs can apply, though courts consider the purpose and proportionality of the examination.
Q: Can documents be produced at an S596 examination?
A: Yes. A summons can require the examinee to produce books and documents of the company. The documents can then be inspected and used by the liquidator in their investigations and proceedings.
Q: Are examinations public?
A: Section 596 examinations are typically held in open court and are publicly accessible, though the court can restrict access in appropriate cases. The transcript is a court document. This can be significant for HNW examinees concerned about reputational exposure.
Q: Can a third party bank be examined?
A: Yes—under s596B, a court may issue a summons to a third party such as a bank, accountant, or adviser who has relevant information. This is a powerful tool for tracing funds and understanding the company’s financial dealings.
Q: What is the interaction between an S596 examination and a police investigation?
A: Where criminal conduct is suspected, ASIC and the police may also be investigating. Self-incrimination privilege and the use-of-evidence protections under s128 Evidence acts are critical considerations. Legal representation at examination is essential in these circumstances.