Director & Shareholder Disputes — Boyle Litigation Lawyers
When a director is stripping assets, blocking access to company records, or acting in breach of their duties, speed is the difference between a remedy and a hollow judgment. An interlocutory injunction—sought on an urgent basis—is the tool that stops the damage while the dispute resolves.
Dispute moving fast?
Book a confidential strategy call
What Is an Interlocutory Injunction?
An interlocutory injunction is a court order made before a final hearing that restrains a party from doing something—or compels them to do something—pending the outcome of litigation. In shareholder and director disputes, common applications include:
- Restraining a director from transferring, dissipating, or encumbering company assets
- Preventing a director from resigning, executing documents, or entering transactions without board approval
- Restraining a majority shareholder from passing resolutions that oppress the minority
- Compelling production of company books and records under s247A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
- Preventing removal of a director pending an S232 oppression application
The jurisdiction to grant interlocutory injunctions sits primarily in the Supreme Court of Queensland (and in the Federal Court where Corporations Act matters are involved).
The Legal Test: American Cyanamid
Courts apply the test in American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396, as adopted in Australia: Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618. The applicant must establish:
1. Serious Question to Be Tried
The applicant does not need to prove their case at the injunction stage. They need to show there is a serious question—not a fanciful one—that warrants determination. This is a relatively low threshold in practice, particularly where director duty breaches are evident on the face of the evidence.
2. Balance of Convenience
The court weighs the hardship to the applicant if the injunction is refused against the hardship to the respondent if it is granted. In asset dissipation cases, courts are generally willing to act where the risk of irreparable harm is real and the respondent’s conduct is commercially inexplicable.
3. Undertaking as to Damages
The applicant must give an undertaking to compensate the respondent for loss caused by the injunction if the applicant ultimately fails. Courts assess whether the applicant has the financial capacity to meet this undertaking.
Urgency: Ex Parte Applications
Where the matter is genuinely urgent—a director is moving assets today, or a transaction is about to settle—an application can be made ex parte (without notice to the other side). The court may grant short-term orders (typically 2-7 days) to preserve the position until the respondent can be heard.
Ex parte orders carry a strict duty of full and frank disclosure. The applicant must put before the court all material facts, including those that may favor the respondent. Failure to do so risks the injunction being discharged with adverse consequences.
Once ex parte orders are in place, the matter is typically listed for an inter partes hearing (with both sides present) within days. At that hearing the respondent can argue the orders should be discharged or varied.
Common Scenarios in Director and Shareholder Disputes
Asset Dissipation
A director or controller is transferring company assets to related parties, paying unsecured creditors selectively, or converting company property to personal use. A freezing injunction (Mareva order) prevents dissipation pending judgment.
Wrongful Exclusion from Management
A majority shareholder uses their voting power to remove a director-shareholder from the board, exclude them from management decisions, or block their access to financial information. An injunction can restrain the removal pending an S232 oppression proceeding.
Restraining Unauthorised Transactions
A director proposes to enter a significant transaction—sale of a business, major borrowing, or related-party deal—without proper board authority. An injunction can prevent the transaction pending ratification or court determination.
Corporate Opportunity Seizure
A director is diverting business opportunities to a competing entity they control. An injunction can restrain the director from pursuing the opportunity and compel an account of what has already been taken.
Anton Piller Orders (Search Orders)
Where there is strong evidence that a party will destroy documents or evidence, an Anton Piller order (now called a search order under the Federal Court Rules) can be sought. It requires the respondent to permit the applicant’s lawyers to enter premises and inspect, copy, or seize evidence without prior notice. These orders are rarely granted and require a very high evidentiary threshold.
Practical Steps: Moving Quickly
If you believe urgent injunctive relief is needed:
- Instruct lawyers immediately—preparation of affidavit material and draft orders takes time
- Preserve all evidence of the conduct complained of (documents, emails, transaction records, board minutes)
- Identify assets at risk and their location so orders can be appropriately targeted
- Be prepared to give the undertaking as to damages and have evidence of your financial capacity
- Expect to file in the Supreme Court of Queensland or Federal Court depending on the nature of the dispute
Boyle Litigation has experience moving at speed to secure urgent orders. We understand the court’s requirements and can prepare applications at short notice when the situation demands it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How quickly can an injunction be obtained?
A: In genuine emergencies, courts can list urgent matters the same day or next day. An ex parte application can be made with minimal notice where there is real risk of immediate harm. The practical bottleneck is usually the preparation of affidavit evidence—the stronger and more focused the evidence, the faster the application.
Q: What does it cost to apply for an urgent injunction?
A: Preparation of urgent injunction applications is resource-intensive—affidavits, supporting exhibits, draft orders, court appearance—and costs can be substantial. However, the cost of not acting while assets are dissipated or a business is destroyed is usually far greater. We provide clear cost estimates before commencing.
Q: Can an injunction be obtained against a director personally?
A: Yes. Where a director is acting in breach of their duties—whether statutory duties under ss180-184 of the Corporations Act or fiduciary duties—an injunction can be sought against them personally as well as against the company.
Q: What happens if a party breaches an injunction?
A: Breach of a court injunction is contempt of court, which can result in fines, sequestration of assets, or imprisonment. Courts take breaches seriously. Where a party breaches orders, an application for contempt should be made promptly to preserve the integrity of the orders.
Q: Is an injunction the same as a freezing order?
A: A freezing order (formerly called a Mareva injunction) is a specific type of interlocutory injunction that restrains a party from dealing with assets up to the value of the applicant’s claim. It is the most common form of urgent relief sought in shareholder and director disputes involving asset dissipation.
Q: Do I need to tell the other side before applying?
A: Not always. Where the risk of harm is immediate and there is a real risk that notice would cause the respondent to accelerate their conduct, an ex parte application can be made. However, courts require you to explain why notice was not given, and orders made ex parte are usually only temporary.