Freezing Orders in Shareholder Disputes: Protecting Assets Before Judgment

Director & Shareholder Disputes — Boyle Litigation Lawyers

A judgment you cannot enforce is worthless. If the other side is moving assets, a freezing order—also called a Mareva injunction—stops them in their tracks. It is one of the most powerful tools available in shareholder and director disputes, and it can be obtained urgently, before the other side has any warning.

Assets at risk?

Book a confidential strategy call

What Is a Freezing Order?

A freezing order is a court order that prevents a person or entity from disposing of, dealing with, or diminishing the value of their assets up to a specified amount—typically the value of the applicant’s claim. In Queensland, the jurisdiction to grant freezing orders is established under r.260C of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) and in the Federal Court under r.7.35 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).

Freezing orders can cover:

  • Bank accounts (including specific account numbers)
  • Real property (preventing sale, transfer, or encumbrance)
  • Shares and other securities
  • Business assets and equipment
  • Assets held by third parties for the respondent’s benefit
  • Assets held overseas (worldwide freezing orders in appropriate cases)

The Legal Test for a Freezing Order

To obtain a freezing order, the applicant must satisfy the court of three things:

1. Good Arguable Case

The applicant must show a good arguable case on the merits—a higher threshold than the ‘serious question’ test for ordinary interlocutory injunctions: Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380. In practice this means the claim must be more than arguably available; it must be reasonably strong on the evidence before the court.

2. Real Risk of Dissipation

The applicant must establish that there is a real risk that, unless restrained, the respondent will dissipate or deal with their assets in a manner that would frustrate any judgment. Courts look for objective evidence of that risk—unexplained asset transfers, offshore dealings, conduct indicating flight risk, or a pattern of conduct in the dispute that demonstrates the respondent will not respect a judgment.

3. Balance of Convenience

As with all interlocutory orders, the court weighs the harm to the applicant (if no order is made and assets disappear) against the harm to the respondent (if orders are made and they are innocent). An applicant must give the usual undertaking as to damages.

Freezing Orders in Shareholder Disputes: When They Arise

Director Stripping Assets

A director in a deadlocked company begins transferring assets to related entities, repaying debts to associated parties, or liquidating business assets ahead of a shareholder buyout dispute. A freezing order preserves the value of the company—and by extension the value of the shares—pending resolution.

Post-Oppression Judgment Enforcement

Where a court has made a buyout order under s233 of the Corporations Act (following a successful s232 oppression claim), but the respondent begins moving funds to avoid paying the ordered price, a freezing order can protect the enforceability of the order.

Breach of Fiduciary Duty — Profits Received

A director has taken a corporate opportunity or secret commission. The amount of profit is not yet quantified but is clearly substantial. A freezing order preserves assets equal to the likely account of profits pending a final order.

Pre-Judgment Asset Protection

A shareholder lawsuit is on foot but still some time from trial. During that period, the respondent begins winding down operations, transferring property, or restructuring. A freezing order ensures the end of the litigation has something to enforce against.

Worldwide Freezing Orders

Where there is evidence that assets are held offshore or are being moved out of the jurisdiction, courts can grant worldwide freezing orders. These are more difficult to obtain — the threshold for evidence of offshore dealings is higher—but are available in appropriate cases. Enforcement overseas depends on the applicable jurisdiction’s recognition of Australian court orders, which varies.

Third Party Freezing Orders

In Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380, the High Court confirmed that freezing orders can in appropriate circumstances be made against third parties who are not defendants to the proceeding but who hold assets of or for the benefit of the defendant. This is significant in disputes where assets have already been moved to related entities or family members.

Practical Considerations

  • Freezing orders are usually obtained ex parte (without notice) where there is genuine urgency and a risk that giving notice would cause the respondent to accelerate asset movements
  • The applicant’s lawyers must make full and frank disclosure of all material facts, including any that assist the respondent
  • Once in place, the respondent can apply to vary or discharge the order at an inter partes hearing
  • Orders typically allow the respondent living expenses and ordinary business expenses to avoid oppressive operation
  • Asset disclosure orders often accompany freezing orders—the respondent must swear an affidavit disclosing all their assets

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can a freezing order be obtained against a company rather than just an individual?

A: Yes. Freezing orders can be obtained against individuals, companies, or both. Where a director has moved assets to a company they control, the order can be sought against both the individual and the corporate vehicle.

Q: How long does a freezing order last?

A: An ex parte order is usually short-term (days) until the matter can be heard with both parties present. If maintained at the inter partes hearing, the order continues until trial or further order. It is not permanent—it preserves the status quo during the litigation.

Q: What assets can be frozen?

A: Any asset of the respondent up to the value of the claim—bank accounts, real property, shares, business assets, vehicles, and in some cases assets held by third parties. The order is usually capped at the amount of the applicant’s claim plus an allowance for costs.

Q: Does a freezing order prevent normal business operations?

A: Orders are typically carved out to allow ordinary living expenses and normal business expenses. A respondent who is running a business can apply to the court to have the order varied to allow specific transactions. Courts do not intend freezing orders to shut down legitimate businesses.

Q: What if the other party breaches the freezing order?

A: Breach of a freezing order is contempt of court. Applications for contempt can result in fines, sequestration of assets, and imprisonment. Enforcement is taken seriously by courts. If you become aware of a breach, legal advice should be sought immediately.

Q: Can a freezing order be obtained before commencing proceedings?

A: Yes. Pre-action freezing orders are available in some circumstances where proceedings are imminent and the urgency of the situation requires action before the main proceeding is filed. Courts have discretion to grant relief in advance of, or concurrent with, the filing of proceedings.

Related Articles

Explore more insights, legal updates, and practical guidance from our litigation experts.
Scroll to Top